When Consequences Hurt: Why Severe Depression After Domestic Violence Charges Is a Reason for Custodial Care, Not a Shield Against Accountability

Updated: Oct 28
A Quick Note Before You Read: This article contains frank discussions of domestic violence, non-fatal strangulation, severe depression, and suicide risk inside custody. While our focus here is strictly clinical and analytical rather than sensationalised, these are heavy topics that can hit close to home. Please take care of yourself while reading, and if you are not in the headspace for this kind of material today, please feel free to click away and sit this one out. (Crisis and family violence support numbers are also listed at the bottom of this page if you need them.)
Imagine reading the news over your morning coffee as an increasingly familiar story unfolds in Australian public life. A well-known man with a lucrative wellness brand, a curated public image of family devotion, and millions of dollars in commercial partnerships is led into the dock from the police watch house. He stands accused of a terrifying act behind closed doors: choking his wife until she could no longer draw breath and banging her head against the floor until she believed she was going to die. And almost before the ink on the police charge sheet is dry, a familiar clinical document is handed up to the bench. A psychologist's report states that the accused is now suffering from extremely severe depression. His legal counsel argues that because his psychological state is deteriorating, and because his professional career is taking a beating, he ought to be released on bail.
If you felt a visceral flash of anger or exhaustion reading those court reports this week, your nervous system is registering something deeply important. For decades, survivors of family violence, legal advocates, and everyday Australians have watched a recurring pattern play out in our justice system and media cycle. While a person maintains power, status, and control in private, mental illness is rarely mentioned in their profile. Yet the exact moment police intervene, handcuffs click shut, and the social, financial, and legal consequences of alleged violence arrive at the front door, a clinical diagnosis materialises as a proposed exit ramp from custody. It leaves the public feeling as though the language of psychology is being weaponised to soften the edges of alleged brutality.
And at the same time, if we are going to speak about this with clinical and human integrity, we have to hold a second truth in the room without flinching. We do not want a person sitting in a remand cell to take their own life. When a human being is placed in a high-security correctional facility, stripped of their liberty, and confronted with the overnight collapse of their reputation and family, their despair is often real, acute, and dangerous. Recognising that reality is not softness. It is basic medical ethics.
The problem is not that courts are asked to notice a defendant's psychological distress. The problem is the leap in logic that says severe depression in the wake of an arrest is a reason to open the cell door and return a high-risk defendant to the community. When we look at the actual clinical mechanics underneath this debate, a much clearer truth emerges: experiencing crushing depression when facing catastrophic legal, financial, social, and moral consequences for alleged violence is an entirely predictable human reaction, and while that distress warrants robust psychiatric care inside custody, mental illness must never be used as a shield against accountability and social responsibility.

A Fair Summary of the Core Issue
To examine this tension fairly, we need to look strictly at the facts placed on the public record without prejudging the ultimate criminal trial. As reported by Ben Smee in The Guardian Australia, 46-year-old Melbourne wellness influencer and former reality television figure Sam Wood is preparing to petition the Queensland Supreme Court for bail, more than two weeks after a Sunshine Coast court ordered that he remain behind bars.
Wood was arrested at Noosa on 4 October 2026 and charged with two serious domestic violence offences: assault occasioning bodily harm and strangulation in a domestic setting. Under Queensland law, strangulation in a domestic context carries a statutory presumption against bail, meaning the accused bears the legal burden of showing cause as to why their continued detention is not justified.
During the initial bail hearing on the Sunshine Coast, police prosecutor Jeanette Grigoris informed the court that Wood's wife, Snezana, was supportive of the charges. The prosecution alleged that during the incident at Noosa, there was a cessation of breath while she was choked. In the words of the prosecutor: "She articulates the banging of her head on the floor. She couldn't breathe. She thought she was going to die." Police opposed bail by tendering evidence regarding a similar alleged incident in Victoria roughly three years earlier, arguing before the magistrate that the defendant's behaviour was escalating.
In response, defence lawyer Matthew Cuskelly stated that his client denied the allegations. To argue that Wood should be granted bail despite the statutory presumption against it, the defence relied heavily on two intertwined pillars: his deteriorating mental health and the commercial survival of his public career. Tendering a psychologist's report that classified Wood's depression as "extremely severe," his lawyer argued that he ought to be given the opportunity to engage with mental health professionals in the community, adding that release would allow him to "try to salvage something of his professional reputation and career, which is taking a hell of a beating at the moment."
Framing the backdrop to the arrest, the defence told the court: "Ultimately, as all families have, there was problems. And my client had been enduring the hardship of attempting to quarantine those problems from his family for some period of time. It was agonising." Following four days in the Maroochydore police watch house, Wood was transferred to the high-security Wolston Correctional Centre near Brisbane, where he remains on remand ahead of next month's Supreme Court bail review.
It is vital to state clearly that every accused person in Australia is entitled to the presumption of innocence at trial, and defence counsel has a professional duty to advance every lawful argument available to secure their client's liberty. Yet the arguments advanced in that courtroom do not stay sealed in a legal transcript. They enter the bloodstream of our national conversation about family violence, psychiatric diagnosis, and what happens when powerful men face the checks and measures of our society.
Under the Hood: A Deeper Psychological Perspective
When a psychologist's report is tendered in a bail application citing "extremely severe depression," the public is often left with a binary choice: either we believe the defendant is faking his distress to manipulate the court, or we believe he is genuinely unwell and therefore belongs in a private clinic rather than a prison cell.
In a quiet consulting room, neither of those binary options holds up to scrutiny. We do not need to question the authenticity of a defendant's low mood to reject the idea that it entitles him to bail. When we look under the hood at the psychological, forensic, and neurobiological mechanisms involved, four distinct clinical realities come into focus.
1. Reactive Collapse Versus Exculpatory Pathology: When Consequences Hurt
First, we need to talk plainly about what depression actually is in the wake of a catastrophic life event, and how a standard clinical questionnaire measures it.
When a person sits down with a psychologist in a police watch house or remand centre and completes a psychometric screening tool (such as the Depression Anxiety Stress Scales or the Beck Depression Inventory), the instrument asks a series of symptom-based questions. Can you experience positive feelings? Are you having trouble sleeping? Do you feel hopeless about the future? Does your life feel like it has lost its meaning? Are you experiencing physical agitation or a heavy, leaden paralysis in your limbs?
Think about what happens to a person's nervous system when they are arrested at a holiday resort, placed in a concrete watch house cell, charged with choking their partner, splashed across the front page of every newspaper in the country, and stripped of their business dealings within forty-eight hours. Their sympathetic nervous system fires into sheer panic, followed rapidly by a dorsal vagal shutdown: the heavy, immobilising biological collapse that occurs when a human organism realises there is no quick escape from an overwhelming threat.
Of course that person scores in the "extremely severe" range on a depression inventory. How could they not? If a person stood accused of strangling their wife, watched their marriage, liberty, social standing, and multi-million-dollar enterprise disintegrate in real time, and scored in the "normal, cheerful, well-adjusted" range on a mood assessment, a clinician would not celebrate their mental health. We would be deeply concerned that we were looking at profound callous-unemotional traits, delusion, or psychopathy.
Feeling crushed, terrified, ashamed, and severely depressed when your actions (or the grave legal accusations surrounding your actions) bring your world crashing down is not an anomaly. It is a proportionate, functional nervous system response to catastrophic legal, financial, social, and moral consequences.
"Wait," a legal advocate might say, "does the origin of the depression matter if the clinical severity is the same?"
In a forensic and ethical sense, it matters enormously. In clinical psychology, we draw a sharp distinction between an exculpatory or mitigating pathology (such as an acute, unmedicated psychotic episode where a person loses contact with reality and cannot comprehend the wrongfulness of their act) and reactive consequence distress (the acute despair that floods in after the sirens arrive and the social bill comes due).
Below is how we differentiate these two presentations when evaluating behaviour and accountability:
Clinical Dimension | Mitigating / Exculpatory Pathology | Reactive Consequence Distress |
Temporal Onset | Present and severe prior to the incident; directly impairs reality testing or impulse regulation during the event. | Emerges or spikes into the "extremely severe" range after police intervention, arrest, and public exposure. |
Primary Trigger | Neurobiological dysregulation, delusional belief systems, or severe trauma reactivation independent of legal capture. | Loss of liberty, reputational collapse, financial ruin, relational rupture, and the visceral shock of incarceration. |
Cognitive Focus | Disorganised, internally driven, or detached from external social calculations. | Intensely focused on external fallout: salvaging career, avoiding prison, and managing public perception. |
Functional Role of Emotion | Symptomatic expression of an underlying psychiatric illness requiring medical stabilisation. | A painful but intact moral and biological alarm signalling that one's life and social standing are in crisis. |
Appropriate Institutional Response | Forensic psychiatric diversion or hospitalisation if legal capacity is compromised. | Secure containment on remand with in-reach correctional mental health support and suicide observation. |
When we conflate reactive consequence distress with a reason to suspend legal accountability, we turn human biology upside down. Painful emotions like shame, grief, dread, and reactive depression exist in our evolutionary wiring for a reason. They are the heavy, unmistakable signals that tell us a boundary of immense significance has been crossed. To argue that a man must be released from custody because the consequences of his alleged violence are making him severely depressed is akin to arguing that a patient should not undergo surgery because the negative results of a diagnostic scan gave them a panic attack. The distress is real. And the distress is a direct product of the crisis that requires containment and management.
2. The Neurobiology of Non-Fatal Strangulation: Why Safety Trumps Reputation
Second, we cannot evaluate a bail application involving mental health and career damage in a vacuum. We have to weigh those arguments against the specific neurobiological and criminological reality of the charge on the indictment: strangulation in a domestic setting.
Why did the Queensland Parliament (alongside legislatures across Australia) rewrite its bail and criminal statutes to make domestic strangulation a standalone felony carrying a presumption against bail? Because in the empirical literature on intimate partner homicide, non-fatal strangulation is not treated as just another form of physical assault. It is the single most powerful clinical and statistical red flag for future lethal violence.
When we look at the physiology of choking, the margin between a non-fatal assault and a homicide is measured in seconds and pounds of pressure. It takes less than five kilograms of pressure on the carotid arteries to occlude blood flow to the brain, less than the force required to open a can of soft drink. Within ten seconds of sustained compression, cerebral hypoxia begins and consciousness starts to fade. Within minutes, irreversible hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury or death occurs. Even when a victim survives without visible external bruising on the neck (which occurs in roughly half of all clinical cases), they frequently sustain microscopic internal trauma, vascular dissection, thyroid cartilage micro-fractures, and profound neurological terror.
Psychologically, as psychiatrist Judith Herman documented in her foundational work on trauma and coercive control, strangulation is the ultimate demonstration of omnipotent control over another human being's life. When a perpetrator closes their hands around a partner's throat until breath ceases and their head strikes the floor, the message delivered directly to the victim's brainstem is unmistakable: You live or die at my discretion. That is why the prosecutor's statement in the Sunshine Coast court ("She couldn't breathe. She thought she was going to die") carries such immense forensic weight. A person who genuinely believes they are taking their final breath undergoes an acute traumatic encoding that alters their autonomic nervous system long after the physical grip is released.
Now, step back and place the two courtroom arguments side by side on a set of clinical scales.
On one side of the scale is a woman who allegedly experienced the cessation of breath and the terror of imminent death, backed by police evidence alleging a prior similar incident in Victoria three years ago and a pattern of escalating risk. On the other side of the scale is a submission from defence counsel that the accused is severely depressed and needs to be released so he can engage with his own mental health professionals and "try to salvage something of his professional reputation and career, which is taking a hell of a beating at the moment."
Let us sit with the phrase taking a hell of a beating for a moment.
In a hearing concerning an alleged physical beating and strangulation, using the metaphor of a career "taking a beating" reveals a profound distortion in how our culture weighs male status against female physical safety. A wellness brand is an economic asset. A public reputation is a social construct. Both can be rebuilt, restructured, or changed. A human life cannot be revived once it is permanently lost.
In trauma-informed clinical practice, rule number one (established across every major psychiatric manual for the past forty years) is that safety precedes all other therapeutic work. No recovery, no reconciliation, and no community management can occur while the primary threat to a survivor's survival remains uncontained during the volatile window immediately following separation and police intervention. We know from Australian domestic homicide reviews that the weeks immediately following a police call-out, an arrest, and a victim's decision to support criminal charges represent the exact peak window of lethality. When a high-status individual loses their career, their marriage, and their public facade simultaneously, the psychological state of having "nothing left to lose" is precisely what makes community release so perilous. Severe depression in an accused perpetrator does not lower the statistical risk to a complainant; in forensic risk assessment, acute despair combined with catastrophic loss of status significantly elevates the risk of catastrophic escalation.
3. The "All Families Have Problems" Minimisation Trap
Third, we need to examine the psychological framing offered to the court to explain the lead-up to the arrest. In the transcript reported by The Guardian, defence counsel stated: "Ultimately, as all families have, there was problems. And my client had been enduring the hardship of attempting to quarantine those problems from his family for some period of time. It was agonising."
As a clinical psychologist who works with individuals and couples navigating relational distress, I hear variations of this language frequently. It is worth unpacking with precision, because it illustrates how protective self-narratives operate when a person is trying to reconcile their self-image as a "good family man" with allegations of frightening behaviour.
Notice the three linguistic moves inside those two sentences:
Universal Normalisation ("Ultimately, as all families have, there was problems"): By placing the household dynamics inside the universal bucket of ordinary family stress, the statement blurs the categorical boundary between relational conflict and domestic violence. All families experience conflict, financial strain, miscommunication, exhausted parenting, and periods of emotional distance. Those are mutual relational problems. Allegedly choking a partner until her breathing stops is not a "family problem." It is a unilateral act of physical violence. Conflating the two invites the listener to view an alleged criminal assault as an unfortunate spillover of everyday domestic friction.
Heroic Self-Sacrifice ("Enduring the hardship of attempting to quarantine those problems from his family"): Look at how the agency and victimhood are inverted here. The accused is cast not as an active agent making behavioural choices, but as a stoic protector suffering silently while trying to "quarantine" hardship away from his loved ones. In clinical work with men who use control or violence in relationships, we see this cognitive distortion constantly. A man feels overwhelmed by internal shame, business pressure, or emotional inadequacy. Rather than acknowledging his vulnerability or addressing his accountability to his circumstances, he attempts to suppress and control the surrounding environment instead. Because that internal suppression feels exhausting ("agonising"), he experiences himself as the primary victim of the stress, right up until the moment his control snaps into external aggression.
Externalising the Rupture: When violence is framed as the tragic byproduct of "agonising hardship" and "severe depression," the behaviour itself becomes weightless. Nobody did anything; rather, "problems" happened, "hardship" was endured, and a "psychological state deteriorated."
In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT), one of the first things we do in the consulting room is gently strip away these fog-inducing abstractions and return to clean, observable behavioural language. We separate internal private experiences (thoughts, depressive feelings, anxiety, business stress, agonising pressure) from overt external behaviour (what your hands, voice, and body actually did in the room).
Here is the core clinical distinction that holds up every ethical therapeutic framework: Your internal pain is valid, and your external behaviour is your responsibility.
A person can be enduring agonising internal hardship. They can be carrying severe, crushing depression. They can be terrified that their business or marriage is failing. Every single one of those feelings deserves a compassionate ear before a crisis occurs. And none of those feelings moves a person's hands to another human being's throat. Feelings do not have fingers. Stress does not bang a partner's head against the floor. Between the firing of an agonising emotion in the limbic system and the execution of a physical act, there is behavioural choice. Holding that line is not a lack of empathy for men's mental health. In fact, insisting that distressed men remain moral agents capable of choosing non-violence is the only way we treat men as capable adults rather than ticking biological time bombs.
"Wait," a neurobiologically minded reader or hard determinist might argue, "what if there truly wasn't a choice in that split second? When the limbic system floods with rage or despair and the prefrontal cortex goes offline in an amygdala hijack, isn't the physical act biologically determined?"
Let us take that deterministic argument seriously and follow it to its two logical conclusions.
First, in clinical reality, domestic violence is almost never a global failure of the motor cortex. Even at the height of "agonising" business and personal stress, a person who claims they "snapped" or "lost control" almost always retains complete inhibitory control in public. They do not choke their business partners during a tense board meeting. They do not bang a colleague's head against the floor when a commercial contract falls through. They do not strangle the arresting police officer on the driveway. When a nervous system only "loses control" in private, behind closed doors, with a physically smaller intimate partner where there are no witnesses, we are not looking at an involuntary neurological seizure. We are looking at a conditioned, context-specific behaviour governed by perceived permission and power.
Second, even if we were to accept the strict deterministic premise that a person's brain wiring leaves them completely unable to stop themselves from choking their partner when under severe stress, notice what that means for a bail application. It does not become an argument for release. It becomes the ultimate forensic argument for secure containment. If you tell a court, "My nervous system is deterministically wired to respond to agonising stress with lethal force, and I have no conscious choice in the matter," then society has an immediate duty to place a locked door between your nervous system and the community until that risk is neutralised. Whether we view human action through the lens of moral agency or biological determinism, the protective boundary remains identical.
4. Care Inside Containment: Why Prison Mental Health Support Exists
Finally, let us address the central practical question at the heart of this public debate: If an accused person is experiencing extremely severe depression and we genuinely want to keep him alive and safe from suicide, does he need to be released on bail to receive treatment?
The short answer is no. And pretending that community release is the only way to deliver acute psychiatric care misunderstands both how acute crisis stabilization works and how our correctional health systems operate.
When a person in the general community presents to an emergency department with extremely severe depression, acute situational collapse, and a high risk of self-harm or harm to others, what do psychiatrists and clinical psychologists do? We do not hand them a business card for a weekly outpatient wellness retreat and send them back into the exact chaotic environment where the crisis erupted. When risk is acute, the clinical standard of care is containment, observation, and environmental stabilisation.
Inside a high-security remand facility like Wolston Correctional Centre in Queensland (or Ravenhall and the Metropolitan Remand Centre here in Victoria), prisoners do not exist in a medical vacuum. State correctional facilities operate dedicated custodial mental health services staffed by forensic psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, mental health nurses, and crisis support officers. When an inmate on remand is identified via psychological assessment as having extremely severe depression, correctional health protocols provide for:
Immediate Risk Assessment and At-Risk Management: Placement in a safe assessment cell or specialised medical observation unit designed to eliminate ligature points and environmental hazards.
Psychiatric and Pharmacological Intervention: Direct evaluation by a custodial psychiatrist capable of initiating or adjusting antidepressant, anxiolytic, or sleep-stabilising medication under daily nursing supervision.
Structured Psychological Triage: Crisis counselling focused on distress tolerance, nervous system down-regulation, and surviving the acute shock of remand without self-harm.
Independent Legal and Clinical Access: Provisions for private forensic psychologists and psychiatrists retained by the defence to visit the correctional centre, conduct assessments, and provide treatment alongside state health staff.
Let us be candid and realistic here. Is a high-security prison a pleasant, soothing environment for a person's mental health? No. Prison is austere, loud, restrictive, and frightening, particularly for a first-time remandee accustomed to luxury and autonomy. And is Australia's custodial mental health system stretched thin and in constant need of greater public funding? Without question.
Yet there is a vast difference between advocating for robust psychiatric care inside Wolston Correctional Centre and arguing that a defendant charged with non-fatal strangulation should be released into the community so he can consult his preferred private practitioners and manage his public relations crisis.
Think about the precedent that argument attempts to set. Every single night across Australia, thousands of people sit in police watch houses and remand centres facing serious violent charges. The vast majority of them do not have the financial resources to commission a private psychological report within days of their arrest, nor do they have a high-profile brand to salvage. Many of them are experiencing crushing depression, drug withdrawal, trauma reactivation, and profound despair over the loss of their freedom and families. If "feeling severely depressed because I was arrested and my life is falling apart" were sufficient legal grounds to overturn the statutory presumption against bail for domestic strangulation, the presumption against bail would cease to exist. Or worse: it would cease to exist exclusively for wealthy, articulate men who can afford to translate their acute shock into a clinical dossier within seventy-two hours.
True compassion for a defendant in crisis does not require us to gamble with a complainant's physical safety or dismantle the legal threshold for bail. True compassion says: We take your severe depression seriously. We do not want you to die by suicide. Therefore, we will wrap medical observation, psychiatric medication, and psychological support around you right where you are, inside the secure perimeter of the remand centre, while the justice system does its job. Both are strong.
The Melbourne & Australian Context
While the legal proceedings involving Sam Wood are unfolding in the Queensland courts between the Sunshine Coast and Brisbane, the shockwaves of this case are felt acutely here in Melbourne and across Victoria. Not only is Melbourne where Wood built his public profile, his fitness empire, and his media career (and where Victorian police records from an alleged incident three years ago have now been tendered in court), but Victorians are currently grappling with a deeply unsettling wave of physical violence and intimidation in the lead-up to our November state election.
In the past week alone, Australians were horrified when independent Victorian federal MP Dr Helen Haines was deliberately struck twice and pinned by a four-wheel drive outside her regional electorate office in Wangaratta, an alleged attack that resulted in the amputation of both of her legs. Days later, Victorian Labor Minister Paul Edbrooke returned to his car to find a live bullet with the word "RAT" etched into it left on his vehicle. And in the Wangaratta Magistrates' Court this week, as the man accused of ramming Dr Haines made his first appearance, his defence lawyer immediately flagged that his client may have been suffering from "potential mental health issues," despite acknowledging he had never previously been diagnosed with a mental health condition.
Across Victoria and Australia more broadly, we are living through a watershed moment in how our institutions respond to gender-based violence and coercive control. Following the landmark Victorian Royal Commission into Family Violence, the ongoing reforms under the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic), and the national cabinet crisis meetings convened in recent years in response to the toll of women killed by intimate partners, Australian states have systematically tightened bail laws and criminal codes around high-risk lethality indicators. Queensland's decision to attach a presumption against bail to strangulation in a domestic setting mirrors a broader national awakening: our courts and parliaments have recognised that when a complainant reports choking, the justice system cannot afford to treat the period between arrest and trial as a benign waiting game.
At the same time, Melbourne and the wider Australian community have invested heavily over the past two decades in destigmatising mental illness, particularly among men. Through tireless public health campaigns led by organisations like Beyond Blue and clinical bodies like the Australian Psychological Society (APS), we have taught Australian men that depression is not a personal weakness, that speaking up about psychological pain is courageous, and that seeking professional help is vital.
That cultural shift has saved countless lives. And it has created an unintended vulnerability that we as Australian clinicians and citizens must now confront honestly.
When mental health literacy rises without an equal rise in accountability literacy, diagnostic language can easily be co-opted in courtrooms, workplaces, and living rooms. Across clinical practices in Melbourne, we regularly sit with survivors of family violence whose partners have used a diagnosis of depression, anxiety, ADHD, or unresolved trauma as an ongoing explanation for why they cannot be held to basic standards of physical and emotional safety. Conversely, when we work with men who have crossed the line into controlling or aggressive behaviour (the core work handled through specialised men's behaviour change frameworks and forensic services like No to Violence), the single greatest barrier to genuine rehabilitation is the tendency to hide behind emotional distress to avoid facing the full moral weight of what they have done.
If the Australian public repeatedly watches high-profile defendants cite severe depression in an effort to bypass domestic violence bail laws and salvage their commercial reputations, two deeply damaging things happen to our culture. First, survivors lose faith that the justice system will prioritise their breathing over their partner's branding. Second, the broader community grows cynical toward men's mental health altogether, starting to view a diagnosis of depression with suspicion rather than empathy. Protecting the integrity of mental health care in Australia requires clinical psychologists to stand up and draw a clear boundary: a diagnosis is a roadmap for treatment and a call for safe containment, never a get-out-of-jail-free card.
Some Humble Takeaways
Whether you are reading this as a clinician, a legal professional, a person navigating a difficult relationship, or someone trying to make sense of how we hold empathy and accountability together in our daily lives, there are practical ways to apply these principles right now. Here are four grounded protocols we use in clinical practice to keep emotional validation and behavioural responsibility in their proper lanes.
1. Practice the "Two-Handed Dialectical Hold"
When someone causes serious harm (or faces credible allegations of harm) and simultaneously collapses into acute emotional distress, our brains are wired to pick one side of the coin. Either we harden our hearts and say, "I don't care if they suffer, they brought this on themselves," or we melt into rescue mode and say, "They are so depressed, we have to let them off the hook so they feel better."
Instead, practice holding both truths in two open hands at the same time using the dialectical "And":
Hand One (Humanity & Care): "This person is experiencing crushing depression and acute panic as their life collapses, and they deserve suicide-safe containment and medical support so they stay alive."
Hand Two (Boundary & Accountability): "And the grave nature of the alleged violence means they must remain securely contained and face the full legal, social, and financial consequences of their actions."
Notice what happens when you replace the word but with and. You no longer have to abandon your humanity to enforce a boundary, and you no longer have to abandon a boundary to care about whether someone lives or dies.
2. Audit "Consequence Distress" Versus "Pre-Existing Remorse"
In everyday relationships, workplaces, and clinical assessments, learn to observe the timing and focus of a person's distress after a boundary violation. When someone is genuinely reckoning with the moral weight of their behaviour, their grief centers on the impact on the other person ("I am horrified by the fear I caused her, and I will accept whatever distance or containment she needs to feel safe").
When distress is primarily driven by reactive consequence collapse, the focus centres almost entirely on self-preservation and reputational fallout ("This is agonising for me, my career is taking a beating, and I need the consequences lifted so I can recover"). Recognising that distinction allows you to offer appropriate support for their distress without prematurely restoring trust or removing protective boundaries.
3. Separate the Feeling from the Action
If you find yourself (or a partner, family member, or client) using emotional states to explain away intimidating, controlling, or aggressive actions, introduce a clean linguistic audit. Write down the narrative on a piece of paper and draw a vertical line down the middle:
Column A (Internal Experience): Write every emotion, stressor, and diagnosis present before and after the event ("I felt overwhelmed, agonised, depressed, ashamed, and terrified of losing my family"). Validate Column A completely. Every human being is allowed to feel those things.
Column B (Observable Behaviour): Write only what a silent security camera in the room would have recorded ("I raised my voice, blocked the doorway, grabbed her, or used physical force").
Then read this sentence aloud: "Column A explains what my nervous system was feeling; Column B is what I chose to do with my body, and I own the consequences of Column B completely." Until a person can keep those two columns distinct without using Column A to erase Column B, genuine psychological repair has not yet begun.
4. Demand Custodial Care, Not Community Risk
As citizens and health professionals, when we hear that a person on remand is suffering from severe mental illness, our advocacy should be directed at strengthening the medical infrastructure inside our correctional centres, not dismantling the bail laws designed to keep complainants alive. We can insist that Queensland Corrective Services (and our own correctional health authorities across Australia) maintain rigorous suicide watch protocols, rapid psychiatric access, and humane conditions on remand, while fully supporting the court's duty to hold high-risk domestic violence defendants in custody until trial.
Closing
When the courtroom doors close and the headlines fade, we are left with a simple, non-negotiable standard that defines a mature society. We can care deeply about suicide prevention and mental health in our prisons without allowing a diagnosis of severe depression to become a shield for alleged domestic violence.
Feeling shattered when your marriage, freedom, finances, and reputation collapse in the wake of an arrest is not a medical exemption from the law; it is the exact weight of social and moral accountability pressing down on the human nervous system. Let us provide every person in custody with the psychiatric care required to keep them safe and alive behind the wire. And let us never confuse a defendant's pain over losing his career with a survivor's right to keep breathing.
Warmly,
Dr Daniel Shaw
Counselling and Clinical Psychologist
Director, Shaw Psychology (Melbourne)
(If you or someone you know is impacted by family or domestic violence, call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732, or the Men's Referral Service on 1300 766 491. For 24/7 crisis support and suicide prevention, contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.)
Looking for a Hand Untangling Complex Relationship or Mental Health Challenges?
At Shaw Psychology in Melbourne, our clinical psychologists, general psychologists and counsellors work collaboratively with individuals and couples to unpack complex emotional distress, trauma recovery, and behavioural accountability in a grounded, non-judgmental space. If you would like to explore support with our team, you are welcome to contact our friendly reception staff or book an initial appointment online.



