top of page

Challenging the Inner Critic: A Guide to Healing Body Image Disturbance in Melbourne

  • Writer: Dr Daniel Shaw
    Dr Daniel Shaw
  • Aug 8
  • 4 min read

For many people struggling with an eating disorder, the battle is not just with food; it's with the person in the mirror. Body image disturbance, or a deeply negative and distorted perception of one's own body, is often the central, driving force behind the illness. It’s a relentless inner critic that dictates self-worth based on weight, shape, and appearance, making true recovery impossible without being addressed directly.


At Shaw Psychology, our Melbourne general and clinical psychologists understand that healing your relationship with your body is as important as healing your relationship with food. This guide explores what body image disturbance is and how evidence-based therapies can help you find peace.


A person gazes at their reflection in a mirror next to a window. The outside view shows lush green trees, suggesting a serene mood.
It is challenging to feel disgust or shame when looking in the mirror, and many people look away to avoid this experience. It doesn't have to be this way, though.

What is Body Image Disturbance?


Body image is more than just what you see; it's how you think, feel, and act towards your body. A healthy body image involves a realistic, accepting, and appreciative perspective. Body image disturbance, however, involves several components:

  • Perceptual Disturbance: A distorted view of your body shape or size (e.g., seeing yourself as much larger than you are).

  • Cognitive Disturbance: Negative and persistent thoughts, beliefs, and assumptions about your appearance (e.g., "If I gain weight, I am a failure").

  • Affective Disturbance: Intense negative emotions like shame, disgust, anxiety, or sadness related to your body.

  • Behavioural Disturbance: Compulsive behaviours like constant body-checking (weighing, mirror-checking, pinching fat), reassurance-seeking, or avoidance of situations that trigger body concerns (like swimming or wearing certain clothes).


This disturbance creates a painful reality where self-esteem is almost exclusively tied to the inner critic's harsh judgments about your body.


The Power of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) for Body Image


While traditional approaches often try to directly challenge or change negative thoughts, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) offers a different path. It's not about learning to love your body, which can feel like an impossible leap. Instead, it’s about changing your relationship with your painful thoughts and feelings, reducing their power over you.

ACT for body image helps you to:

  • Defuse from Unhelpful Thoughts: Learn to see your negative thoughts as just that – thoughts – rather than absolute truths. You learn to observe them without getting "hooked" or controlled by them.

  • Accept Your Private Experiences: Make room for difficult feelings like shame or anxiety without struggling against them. Fighting these feelings often makes them stronger; acceptance lessens their power.

  • Connect with the Present Moment: Use mindfulness skills to anchor yourself in the here and now, rather than being lost in past regrets or future worries about your body.

  • Identify Your Core Values: Discover what truly matters to you in life, separate from appearance (e.g., kindness, connection, creativity, adventure).

  • Take Committed Action: Start taking small, meaningful actions guided by your values, even when difficult body image thoughts and feelings are present.


This process helps you build a rich, full life where your body is simply the vehicle that carries you through it, not the sole measure of your worth.


Hands shape clay on a spinning pottery wheel, forming a cup. The clay is wet and earthy, with focused concentration in the process.
Healing body image involves shifting the focus from what your body looks like to what it allows you to do, create, and experience.

A First Step You Can Take Today: "Thank You, Body"


A powerful exercise, drawn from ACT and self-compassion principles, is to shift your focus from what your body looks like to what your body does for you.

  1. Find a quiet moment. Take a few gentle breaths.

  2. Think of one part of your body. It could be your hands, your feet, your legs, or your lungs.

  3. Instead of judging its appearance, focus on its function. Think about what it allows you to do.

  4. Silently or out loud, say "thank you." For example: "Thank you, hands, for allowing me to type this, to hold a warm cup, to hug someone I love." Or, "Thank you, legs, for carrying me through the park today."


This simple act of gratitude begins to shift your perspective from criticism to appreciation, focusing on function over form.


An Example:

Chloe, a young designer in Melbourne, was in recovery from an eating disorder but remained haunted by her negative body image. She would spend hours scrutinising herself in the mirror and refuse invitations to the beach with friends. In therapy at Shaw Psychology, her psychologist introduced her to ACT. Instead of arguing with her thought "My thighs are huge," she learned to "unhook" from it by saying, "I'm having the thought that my thighs are huge." She also started the "Thank You, Body" exercise. It felt strange at first, but thanking her legs for allowing her to walk her dog and ride her bike slowly began to reduce the power of her inner critic. It wasn't about loving her thighs, but about appreciating them enough to live a life guided by her values of friendship and movement.


(Please note: This is a fictional vignette created for illustrative purposes only.)


Building a More Compassionate Relationship with Your Body


Healing from body image disturbance is a journey of unlearning, compassion, and refocusing on what truly matters. It's about taking the power back from your inner critic so you can live a life of meaning and purpose.


Contact us today on (03) 9969 2190, visit our website at www.shawpsychology.com to learn more, or book an initial consultation directly online here: https://bit.ly/bookshawpsychology.

Comments


bottom of page